Improving the Self-Assessment Tools for Training in
Speaking to Grade Seven Students of Junior High
School
F.Simatupang, Y.Salamanang, A.Tampubolon, F.Sianipar dan N.Sinaga 411
In the context of English teaching and learning, the assessment should cover the
four language skills, namely: listening, speaking, reading, and writing skills. However,
for many years, those four skills have not been assessed equally (Sparks, 2021). There has
been a tendency to put emphasis on assessing reading and writing skills. Permendiknas
No. 34, 2007 concerning “National Examination and Standard Competency of Passing-
Grade” clearly stated that the final examination on English subject only covered the
reading and writing skills. That is why, most of the teachers focused on those reading and
writing skills in the teaching learning process and neglect listening and speaking skills
(Rao, 2019). The ignorance of assessing speaking skill in the foreign language learning
consequently affected students’ ability. More importantly, it also affected teachers’ ability
in assessing speaking skill (Al-Sobhi & Preece, 2018).
The ability to speak \ English is very important for the students because speaking is
the basic language skill for communicating, and the ability to speak well will allow the
students to follow the progress of globalization easily. As a part of communication
speaking is regarded more as representing what the speaker wants to say (Tan, Jospa,
Mohd-Said, & Awang, 2021). Meanwhile, states that speaking is the form of oral
language that is inevitably used to communicate ideas and feelings no matter what the
language is (Nasir, Yusuf, & Wardana, 2019). Furthermore, stated that speaking usually
involve two or more people who use a language for interactional or transactional
purposes. It is not the oral expression of written language (Meena, 2020). According to
these definitions, it can be concluded that speaking is an interaction between two people
or more (Humprecht, 2019). The achievement of good speaking activity is when the
people who interact can understand each other. One obvious example of speaking activity
is the interaction between teacher and students. In the interaction, the teacher should have
good speaking competence because he or she has to bring all of his or her students to
understand the material through his or her speech (Rao, 2019).
Besides, the EFL teachers should be good speakers; they also have to be competent
in assessing their students. Nevertheless, in reality, the English teachers of Junior High
School or “Sekolah Menengah Pertama” (henceforth: SMP) in Pematangsiantar have
faced problems in assessing their students, especially in assessing students’ speaking
ability. The teachers have realized that the weaknesses of the assessments have affected
the results of the students’ achievements (Dietrich et al., 2020). It can be seen from the
output of SMP students, which cannot speak English well. They have failed to
communicate well because of bad English. Meanwhile, it was known that in School SMP
Based Curriculum (KTSP), assessment plays a very significant role since it influences the
students‟ competency significantly (Siagian, 2020). It emphasizes the improvement of
competence through the tasks with specific performance standards so students can
perceive the results as a mastery of a set of specific competencies.The Process standard
which is applied to the latest curriculum (Curriculum 2013) also emphasizes more on the
authentic assessment (Permendikbud No. 81A 2013). Here, authentic assessment is
considered necessary to measure the overall learning outcomes of students (Martin,
Ritzhaupt, Kumar, & Budhrani, 2019). It is because these assessments evaluate the
progress of learning, not merely the result but also the process and other aspects in
different ways. In other words, the assessment system would be fairer to students as
learners, because every effort, which the students produce, will be more appreciated
(Landers, Armstrong, Collmus, Mujcic, & Blaik, 2021). However, there were many
obstacles faced by the teachers in improving authentic assessment especially self-
assessment in the teaching learning process at the school. From the preliminary interview
and questionnaire, it was found that most of the teachers did not implement self-
assessment, especially in speaking skill. The teachers faced problems in implementing